Week 8 was a Chicago heist. The Bears waltzed into Seattle Monday night, hung 34 on the defending champs and walked out with pieces of three different markets in their pockets. The Super Bowl board, MVP Race and Coach of the Year all repriced after last night.
Sunday’s slate pitched in too: a favorite got repo’d, the last unbeaten team finally took an L, and a coach climbed the COY ladder on his week off.
Below: the Bears bleeding into everything, Kenneth Walker's OPOY contract getting repossessed, Jahmyr Gibbs and Jaxon Smith-Njigba turning OPOY into a two-man tug-of-war, Kevin O'Connell's perfect season (and his COY price) dying in Detroit, John Harbaugh extending a lead from his couch, and Jonathan Taylor’s next team before the trade deadline. What moved, why it moved, and where there may be a gap between Kalshi and Polymarket.
A quick note on the numbers. All moves below are Kalshi prices unless stated otherwise. Where Polymarket tells a different story, I've called it out. These are point-in-time figures as of Nov. 3, 2026, and they're subject to change. The screenshots distinguish displayed market probabilities from executable Yes prices; those aren't always the same.
Super Bowl
Chicago Bears (7¢ → 12¢, +5) this is the first market with their paw prints all over it. They’re the violent mover here following last night's trouncing of the Seahawks. The win moved them into the third spot on Kalshi’s board behind the Bills and Niners.
Buffalo (12¢ → 14¢, +2) ticked up a bit to grab the co-lead after blowing out the Lamarless Ravens at home and San Francisco fell down 2¢ to meet them after a bye week.
Nobody's running away as of yet, 8 teams sit between 6¢ and 14¢. Chicago is the one with momentum behind the number, and a soft slate upcoming (Tampa Bay, a bye, then New Orleans) to keep it going. Is 12¢ the start of a real climb, or the market getting a little drunk on one primetime beatdown?
MVP
Josh Allen (33¢) is an immovable object in this market. He's been parked at the top for weeks while everyone underneath him trades chairs. He put up 300+ total yards and 3 TDs in the rout of Ravens in Buffalo to tread water as the favorite this week.
The movable object here is Caleb Williams (6¢ → 11¢, +5 Kalshi; 9¢ → 17¢, +8 Polymarket). Both books corrected after a big Bears win last night but Polymarket seems to be surer of the 3rd year gunslinger’s chance to take the award.
The market paid for Joe Burrow’s move last week, so I guess they thought it was OK to only move him up 2¢ after a six-touchdown performance. He’s sitting passenger to Allen at 20¢. He has 14 TDs in his last three games. Sheesh.
Next three for the top of the board: Allen gets Minnesota on Monday night, @NYJ, then home vs Miami, if he can survive Brian Flores, he has some chances to pad the resume. Burrow draws Atlanta in Madrid, Pittsburgh at home, then @Washington. Williams has Tampa Bay on Sunday night, a Week 10 bye, then New Orleans.
Which book is more correct on Williams right now? And is Burrow getting disrespected after his 6 TD performance?
Offensive Player of the Year
This one has turned into an absolute street fight. Jahmyr Gibbs (24¢ → 39¢, +15) brought a baseball bat to the alleyway with 168 yards and a toudy against a good Vikings defense. Jaxon Smith-Njigba (27¢ → 36¢, +9), found some brass knuckles Monday Night going for 118 and 1.
Somebody had to fund the green for the two leaders above, and this week it was Kenneth Walker III (20¢ → 6¢, −14). He was well within the top three just a week ago and now he's priced as a true longshot. We’ve seen the volatility of this market so it remains to be seen if he’s truly out of the running or if the other two can slip up and allow him to reenter the race.
Next three for the leaders: Gibbs gets a juicy matchup @Miami, New England (Germany), then Tampa Bay, nothing too scary for the Hedgehog to pad the numbers. JSN draws Arizona, @Las Vegas, then a Week 11 bye. This will be a fun one for the next few weeks at least.
Coach of the Year
John Harbaugh (24¢ → 28¢, +4) extended his lead to a commanding 28¢, and his Giants didn't even play. When your closest competition loses, you rise from the couch. He was the preseason favorite for a good part of the summer, and it seems like the market is comfortable with that thesis as the Giants hold the lead in the NFC East.
Kevin O'Connell (15¢ → 3¢, −12) took his first loss and his COY price paid for it. Todd Monken (18¢ → 12¢) faded after getting embarrassed by a divisional opponent and Ben Johnson (8¢ → 19¢, +11) completed the trifecta for the Bears with his rise after MNF.
Next three: Harbaugh comes off the bye at @Philadelphia, then Washington on Thursday, then Jacksonville. Johnson gets Tampa Bay on Sunday night, a bye, then New Orleans. Does Harbaugh's couch-cushion lead survive a real schedule, or does Ben Johnson's Bears story keep eating into it?
Offensive Rookie of the Year
I guess just nobody wants to win this award?
Carnell Tate (22¢ → 13¢, −9) gave back the lead he'd been nursing while doing the same thing with an injury, and the whole board is a scramble underneath
Jonah Coleman (5¢ → 13¢, +8) surged into a tie at the top with Harvey going on IR. Denzel Boston held around 12¢ on Kalshi but cratered on Polymarket (13¢ → 6¢), and Omar Cooper Jr. (11¢ → 5¢) and Germie Bernard (8¢ → 3¢) both got dog-walked in the same matchup.
This book is wildly volatile so trade with caution. When the leader sits at 13¢ and four guys are within a touchdown of him, the market is basically shrugging. Does anyone actually grab this award, or does it stay a wide-open question mark into December?
Defensive Player of the Year
Will Anderson Jr. (34¢ → 30¢) is still the favorite, but this is another week of the market chipping away as he was up in the mid-40s not long ago. No disaster, just slow leakage as the field closes in. The one closing in fastest is T.J. Watt (4¢ → 14¢, +10), who more than tripled to grab a clear second. Fred Warner (9¢ → 13¢, +4) crept up a bit as well. Defensive awards are narrative- and sack-driven, and right now the narrative is drifting off the preseason favorite.
Next three: Anderson gets @LAC, @Cleveland, then Indianapolis on Thursday, pass-rush-friendly spots to stop the bleeding. Watt is on bye in Week 9, then @Cincinnati and @Philadelphia. If Anderson keeps sliding and Watt keeps rising, that 30¢-vs-14¢ gap is the one to watch… is this still Anderson's award, or is the market mid-handoff?
Where the Books Disagree
A few gaps are real enough to flag, with the usual caveat that these only matter where both books are liquid. The thin award longshots aren't disagreements, they're noise. Signals, not free money.
Caleb Williams, MVP: 11¢ Kalshi vs 17¢ Polymarket. The widest gap on a liquid name this week. Polymarket is pricing the Bears hype aggressively; Kalshi's playing it cautious.
Jaxon Smith-Njigba, OPOY: 36¢ Kalshi vs 40¢ Polymarket. The books don't currently agree on who’s the frontrunner. Polymarket has JSN over Gibbs, Kalshi has Gibbs over JSN.
Kansas City, Super Bowl: 7¢ Kalshi vs 8¢ Polymarket. Small, but both books nudged the Chiefs the same way after the Denver loss. Since I didn’t mention them above I figured this was a good spot to keep Mahomes & company in the picture.
On the rookie board, the Kalshi/Poly splits on Boston, Cooper, and Coleman look big in percentage terms but tiny in dollars.
Bonus: The Trade Deadline
One of my favorite markets in football right now isn't even on the award board: where does Jonathan Taylor land before the Nov. 10 deadline? The Colts, who spent the offseason talking about building around him, are suddenly open to moving their All-Pro back, and Schefter and Rapoport have the Broncos, Vikings, Giants, and Seahawks all inquiring.
Where do you think he goes and where do you want him to go?
Week 9: The Swing Factors
Bills @ Vikings, Monday night. Josh Allen's immovable 33¢ against an awesome Vikings defense. A statement here either cements Allen or hands the MVP chasers a crack.
Bears vs Buccaneers, Sunday night. Another primetime spotlight for the team that just moved three markets at once. If Caleb Williams and Ben Johnson keep the Chicago story rolling, Polymarket's aggressive MVP and COY prices get validated… or exposed.
Gibbs @ Miami Gibbs gets a soft matchup to press his new OPOY lead.
Harbaugh @ Philadelphia. The Giants come off the bye into a struggling Philly team.
Let us know in the Discord which one of these flips first for you!
This article includes links to PredictQ partners Kalshi and Polymarket. We may earn a commission if you use them. It doesn't cost you anything extra, and it helps keep the lights on here. Nothing in this piece is investment advice. Market prices and availability can change, and you'll need to meet each platform's age, location, and eligibility requirements.
Who This Is For
These boards read differently depending on why you showed up.
For market traders, this is a watchlist, not a ticket. The moves above show where prices already went. Signal, not free money.
For fantasy players, the board can be a live perception gauge. A price moving on a back like Walker may reflect changing views of volume, role, and health. That's useful context for rest-of-season value, even without trading an award contract.
For readers here for the storylines, this is the awards race as a live scoreboard. Who's pulling away, who tanked, which favorite is one bad Sunday from being a falling knife.
Whatever bucket you're in, these are point-in-time market prices, not my predictions or executable quotes.