Last week was a brake check. This week, somebody floored it.
Week 10 was a statement week for a bunch of these awards. The MVP favorite became a coin flip against the entire field, the OPOY “three-headed monster” lost a head, and the COY frontrunner got knocked back on Thursday night. Here’s what moved, why it moved, and where there may be a gap between Kalshi and Polymarket.
A quick note on the numbers: all line moves below are Kalshi prices unless stated otherwise. Where Polymarket tells a different story, I’ve called it out. All prices recorded are at the time of writing (10 am Tuesday) and are subject to change.

Prices shown above are reflected from my internal data, which gets pulled from Kalshi every Tuesday at 10am.
Last Week’s Swing Factors: The Receipts
We asked four questions last week and the market answered all of them.
Does Burrow hold the belt? He’s about to put it on.
The OPOY logjam? Lost a log.
Harbaugh’s grip? Slipped after a single L.
Where does Jonathan Taylor land? Back on his feet, in the same spot he left. The Colts reportedly turned down second-round picks and kept him, so the 56% favorite cashed.
MVP: Burrow takes a lap
Joe Burrow (32¢ → 48¢, +16) is no longer just leading the race, he’s lapping it. The Bengals put 38 on Pittsburgh on Sunday night, behind Burrow’s 400 & 4, and took over the AFC North. The man was trading around ~6¢ under a month ago, and now he has the biggest lead we’ve seen in the books all year. The Bengals play the Commanders (MNF), Saints and the Browns next.
And then there’s one of the strangest charts of the season. Josh Allen (26¢ → 15¢, −11) had his price fall in a win, for the second week in a row. It’s probably more of a statement to how good Burrow has been in this stretch than it is a knock on Allen, but the Bills are 8-1 and he’s been lights out. To me, 15¢ is way too cheap for a guy with his ceiling, on a team that should be fighting for the one seed in the AFC. He plays the Dolphins this week, who he’s historically dismantled and destroyed, so, I expect a huge week. I am personally going to get in on Josh at this price. Hopefully, I'll have the options of cashing out in the green before Burrow plays Monday or just letting it ride out. Am I getting in on the floor or catching a falling knife?
Brock Purdy sat flat at 16¢ even though the 49ers hung 46 on Dallas, because Christian McCaffrey took the spotlight with three touchdowns. The former Mr. Irrelevant has been top three in the race for weeks and hasn’t shown any signs that he will go out quietly.
Patrick Mahomes (2¢ → 6¢, +4) threw five touchdowns in a 35-13 win over Atlanta and remembered he’s allowed on this list.

Prices shown above are reflected from my internal data, which gets pulled from Kalshi every Tuesday at 10am.
OPOY: Back to a Two-Horse Race (Walker Roundtrips… Again)
The three-headed monster is back to two heads, and both of them ate good this week.
Jahmyr Gibbs (33¢ → 48¢, +15) had 252 yards from scrimmage and two touchdowns in the Lions’ 35-10 throttling of New England in Munich. He tied Terrell Davis’s record for the most touchdowns in a player’s first four seasons. And this season has a lot of game left.
Jaxon Smith-Njigba (28¢ → 43¢, +15; Poly 46¢) matched him point for point. His 71-yard touchdown sealed the win over the Raiders, and he now has 1,207 receiving yards through 10 games. That puts him on pace for Calvin Johnson’s single-season record of 1,964, if he can average just over 108 yards a game the rest of the way.
Two-way race, both of them chasing the award and history along with it.
There must be fallers to fund the risers, and this week it was Kenneth Walker III (18¢ → 5¢, −13). The Chiefs ruled him out with a groin injury, and the buyers didn’t need to wait for an update. For those keeping score at home, Walker has now gone 20¢ → 6¢ → 18¢ → 5¢ in four weeks: repo’d, un-repo’d, and repo’d again. Will he finally settle down?
Coach of the Year: Harbaugh Hits the Wall
Remember “parade by Thanksgiving”? Cancel the floats.
John Harbaugh (35¢ → 18¢, −17) The Giants blew a fourth-quarter lead to Washington on Thursday night. They only had 31 net yards over their last three drives, and Stephen A. was on First Take the next morning calling it “coaching scared.” Not the kind of film COY voters or traders want to rewatch, and he paid for it in the market.
Kyle Shanahan (16¢ → 28¢, +12) is the new leader after the 49ers won a 46-40 shootout in Dallas to move to 8-1. Brutal slate loading in for the Niners though, they get the Vikings, Seahawks and Giants for the next three.
Todd Monken (11¢ → 26¢, +15; Poly 7¢ → 26¢, +19) is right behind him. The Browns erased a 17-point deficit to beat Houston 27-24, with Deshaun Watson getting his revenge game. Cleveland started 4-0 at home for the first time since 1963. The 6-4 Brownies get a Bye week, the Raiders, and the Bengals up next.
One name traders are ignoring: Joe Brady. His Bills are 8-1, he’s the first rookie head coach to start 8-1 since 2022, and he’s sitting at just 3¢. Buffalo is tied at the top of the Super Bowl board and their coach priced like an afterthought. Either voters will punish him for inheriting Josh Allen, or that’s the cheapest ticket on the COY board.
So, is this a three-coach race now, or did one bad Thursday just open a buying window on Harbaugh at 15–18¢?

Prices shown above are reflected from my internal data, which gets pulled from Kalshi every Tuesday at 10am.
ROY: Mendoza Crashes the Food Fight
Up until this week, the ROY was a chaotic food fight that no one wanted to win. Last week, we put Fernando Mendoza on watch, and he showed up.
Fernando Mendoza (6¢ → 25¢, +19) made his first NFL start, ran in a 10-yard touchdown for the Raiders’ first points, and jumped from the back of the board to the front, at 25¢ on both books. The move started after Cousins got traded away, and the market didn’t punish Mendoza for losing his first start to the Super Bowl champs. He got sacked six times by Seattle, but the market stayed confident in pricing him as the favorite. Is this the start of a takeover or an overreaction?
The rest of the food fight lost their plates. Carnell Tate fell to 14¢ (21¢ → 14¢, −7), Denzel Boston slid to 11¢, and Jonah Coleman held steady at 17¢ (Polymarket still loves him at 21¢).
And now there’s a new name: Emmett Johnson debuts at 11¢ after stepping into the Chiefs’ backfield with Walker out. One player’s injury is another player’s opportunity.

Prices shown above are reflected from my internal data, which gets pulled from Kalshi every Tuesday at 10am.
The Quick Hits: Super Bowl Board and DPOY
On the Super Bowl board, the top is now a two-way tie: Buffalo (14¢ → 16¢) and San Francisco (15¢ → 16¢), both 8-1. Jacksonville kept climbing (11¢ → 12¢), while Chicago slipped a touch (13¢ → 11¢). The big mover is Minnesota (2¢ → 8¢, +6). Kirko Chainz is back, the defense sacked Jordan Love eight times in Green Bay, and their title price quadrupled.
In DPOY, Will Anderson Jr. (34¢ → 43¢, +9) is still pulling away. The new riser is Dallas Turner (8¢ → 16¢, +8; Poly 17¢), who was a big part of that eight-sack day against the Packers.
Fred Warner cooled to 18¢. And Aidan Hutchinson is off the board after reports that he got hurt celebrating a play. A painful way to go.
Price Discrepancies: Consensus at the Top, Disagreement Below
Only flagging markets where there is meaningful volume. The thin award longshots are noise, not disagreements.
The books agree almost perfectly on the leaders: Burrow (48¢/50¢), Allen (15¢/15¢), Gibbs (48¢/47¢), Mendoza (25¢/25¢), Anderson (43¢/43¢), Monken (26¢/26¢). The real gaps are just below them:
Jaxon Smith-Njigba (OPOY): Kalshi 43¢ / Polymarket 46¢. Poly is buying the record chase.
John Harbaugh (COY): Kalshi 18¢ / Polymarket 15¢. The gap flipped direction in one week.
Jonah Coleman (ROY): Kalshi 17¢ / Polymarket 21¢. Poly’s rookie crush continues.
Carnell Tate (ROY): Kalshi 14¢ / Polymarket 11¢. Same race, opposite lean.
Joe Brady (COY): Will he get priced as his record?
Jeffrey Simmons shows the biggest raw gap on the board (Kalshi 12¢ / Poly 5¢), but that’s a thin DPOY longshot. Noise, not an edge. Signals, not free money.
Week 11: The Swing Factors
Can anyone dent Burrow? At 48¢, one flat game and Allen may look monstrous in the rear.
JSN’s record pace. He needs just over 108 yards a game to catch Calvin Johnson. Every big week pushes him closer to Gibbs at the top of OPOY.
Is it just a dip on Harbaugh? At 15–18¢, one Giants win makes this week look like an overreaction. One more loss makes it a trend.
Mendoza, start number two. One start got him to 25¢. The second one either confirms it or gives it back.
Let us know in the Discord which one of these flips first for you!
This article reflects market activity and pricing across Kalshi and Polymarket, not directional predictions, trade recommendations, or investment advice. Prices shown are point-in-time and may change and vary by state or jurisdiction. Users must meet each platform’s eligibility and age requirements to trade. PredictQ is a marketing partner of Kalshi and Polymarket and may receive compensation for referrals.
Who This Is For
These boards read differently depending on why you showed up.
For market traders, this is a watchlist, not a ticket. The moves above show where prices already went. Signal, not free money.
For fantasy players, the board can be a live perception gauge. A price moving up like Walker may reflect changing views of volume, role, and health. That's useful context for rest-of-season value, even without trading an award contract.
For readers here for the storylines, this is the awards race as a live scoreboard. Who's pulling away, who tanked, which favorite is one bad Sunday from being a falling knife.
Whatever bucket you're in, these are point-in-time market prices, not my predictions or executable quotes.